President Obama's Real Proposal (And Why It's Risky)
Friday, April 15, 2011 at 12:51AM Paul Ryan says his budget plan will cut $4.4 trillion over ten years. The President says his new plan will cut $4 trillion over twelve years.
Let’s get real. Ten or twelve-year budgets are baloney. It’s hard enough to forecast budgets a year or two into the future. Between now and 2022 or 2024 the economy will probably have gone through a recovery (I’ll explain later why I fear it will be anemic at best) and another downturn. America will also have been through a bunch of elections – at least five congressional and three presidential.
The practical question is how to get out of the ongoing gravitational pull of this awful recession without cow-towing to extremists on the right who think the U.S. government is their mortal enemy. For President Obama, it’s also about how to get reelected.
(Yes, we also have to send a clear signal to global lenders that America is serious about reducing its long-term budget deficit. But in truth, global lenders don’t need much reassurance. Bond market yields in the U.S. are now lower than they were when the government was running a budget surplus ten years ago.)
Seen in this light, Obama’s plan isn’t really a budget proposal. It’s a process proposal.
Stage 1, starting now and ending in June, requires that Republican and Democratic leaders devise a budget for 2012. Apparently they’ve already agreed to try.
That budget would also include a “framework” for deficit reduction over the longer haul. But that framework will be mainly for show. It will give House Republicans enough cover to vote to raise the ceiling on the amount the U.S. government can borrow. (The vote has to occur before the Treasury runs out of accounting maneuvers, in early July.)
And because the framework’s details will be filled in after Election Day, it will give Obama wiggle room before the election to campaign on his priorities. If he wins big – and if Democrats retake the House – its details will look completely different from what they’d look like in the alternative.
Stage 2 occurs in 2014 – fully two years after Election Day. Then, according to Obama’s proposal, if the ratio of the nation’s deficit to the GDP hasn’t fallen to 2.5 percent (it’s now over 10 percent), automatic across-the-board cuts will go into effect to get it there.
Importantly, these cuts wouldn’t apply to Social Security and Medicare, or to Medicaid and other programs designed for the poor. And they wouldn’t be limited to spending. They’d also apply to tax expenditures – that is, to tax deductions and tax credits.
The betting in the White House is that by 2014 the recovery will be in full force, and the economy will have grown so much that the ratio of deficit to the GDP will be in the range of 3 to 5 percent anyway. That means any across-the-board cuts wouldn’t have to be very deep.
The White House is also betting that a strong recovery will take the sting out of any recommendations to slow the growth of Medicare spending emanating from the Medicare board set up under the new health care law (officially known as the Independent Payment Advisory Board.) Under Obama’s new plan, such proposals will be necessary if Medicare spending grows .5 percent faster than growth of the economy (under the law, it’s 1 percent faster).
All told, it’s a clever strategy. It might well avoid a dangerous game of chicken over raising the debt ceiling. It still allows the President to charge Paul Ryan and other Republicans who join him as ending Medicare as we know it – which they are, in fact, proposing to do. (This may help Democrats win back seniors, whose support for Democratic house candidates dropped form 49% in 2006 to 38% in 2010.) And it gives the President lots of room to maneuver between now and Election Day, and between Election Day and 2014.
But there’s one big weakness. The whole thing depends on the recovery picking up steam. If the economy doesn’t, the process could backfire – leading to indiscriminate budget cuts later on, as well as big cuts in Medicare. Indeed, if the recovery fails to fire up, Obama’s own chance of reelection is dimmed considerably, as are the odds of a Democratic House after 2012.
Yet what are the chances of a booming recovery? The economy is now growing at an annualized rate of only 1.5 percent. That’s pitiful. It’s not nearly enough to bring down the rate of unemployment, or remove the danger of a double dip. Real wages continue to drop. Housing prices continue to drop. Food and gas prices are rising. Consumer confidence is still in the basement.
By focusing the public’s attention on the budget deficit, the President is still playing on the Republican’s field. By advancing his own “twelve year plan” for reducing it – without talking about the economy’s underlying problem – he appears to validate their big lie that reducing the deficit is the key to future prosperity.
The underlying problem isn’t the budget deficit. It’s that so much income and wealth are going to the top that most Americans don’t have the purchasing power to sustain a strong recovery.
Until steps are taken to alter this fundamental imbalance – for example, exempting the first $20K of income from payroll taxes while lifting the cap on income subject to payroll taxes, raising income and capital gains taxes on millionaires and using the revenues to expand the Earned Income Tax Credit up to incomes of $50,000, strengthening labor unions, and so on – a strong recovery may not be possible.
Robert Reich is Chancellor's Professor of Public Policy at the University of California at Berkeley. He has served in three national administrations, most recently as secretary of labor under President Bill Clinton. He has written thirteen books, including The Work of Nations, Locked in the Cabinet, Supercapitalism, and his most recent book, Aftershock. His "Marketplace" commentaries can be found on publicradio.com and iTunes.
Democrat, Economy, Federal Budget, GDP, Government, Medicare, Paul Ryan, Republican, Robert Reich 
Reader Comments (11)
True, I would also have included Alvar Aalto. Would also have to take in consideration, that Finland has been under the control of Sweden long time ago. And Iceland should be considered as much part of Scandinavia as is Finland.
-IWC InGenieur / AMG China watch
Excellent tips .I really appreciate all these points, and I agree completely…
Robert Reich is Chancellor's Professor of Public Policy at the University of California at Berkeley. and get some ferragamo shoes sale
furnace filter True, I would also have included Alvar Aalto. Would also have to take in consideration, that Finland has been under the control of Sweden long time ago. And Iceland should be considered as much part of Scandinavia as is Finland.
you may love LG air conditioner
, this is our best online shop with reasonable price air conditioners.
Robert Reich is Chancellor's Professor of Public Policy at the University of California at Berkeley. He has served in three national administrations, most recently as secretary of labor under President Bill Clinton. He has written thirteen books, including The Work of Nations
north face jackets for men
When 1st receiving the boots from ugg boots outlet, you should very first check to see that the boots are in brand new condition. One can by no means be too picky when purchasing UGG boots. As soon as you see that the boots are in brand new condition ugg bailey button, you'll be able to begin the caring procedure for your ugg bailey button.Inspect the component in the sole where it meets the heel. On the real Ugg Australia boots, they have a flush join ugg boots sale, meaning the sole style gradually tapers off into a flat heel. On their fake ugg bailey button sale counterparts, they typically meet at a ridge along with a solid line clearly shows exactly where sole along with the heel meet.Inspect the part in the sole where it meets the heel. On the real ugg bailey button triplet, they've a flush join, which means the sole design gradually tapers off into a flat heel. On their fake counterparts, they usually meet at a ridge plus a solid line clearly shows ugg outlet store sole along with the heel meet.Ugg Australia Argyle boots might be worn slouched or full up. They go best with tights, jeans, a comfy sweater and just about any casual outfit. These will surely be the hottest selling Ugg boots this fall and winter and surely grow to be harder and harder to locate as the cold season comes in ugg classic tall sale.The origins of Uggs are really disputed with both Australia and New Zealand claiming to ugg bailey button triplet sale the originators with the Ugg boot. The term ugg classic short sparkles are in fact a generic term in those countries despite the fact that in the rest in the world the copyright in the term is held by an American business ugg boots clearance.UGG boots appear and really feel wonderful due to the fact in the sheepskin and wool utilised to make every single pair ugg classic short sparkles. Both wool and Sheepskin are very delicate, so your UGGs ought to never be placed in a washing machine or dryer.
Where you might get a rolex air-king watches?Acquiring a rolex sea dweller watches is an excellent solution regarding people who can't buy to purchase one within the genuine manufacturers.You could also obtain a cheap rolex submariner watch if you ever have an original new watch.Essentially, the chances are this rolex new model watches would not secure the very same materials or even attribute the identical custom logo or simply movement.
This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.rolex explorer replica
Among the preferred watches fake companies on the earth, fake cartier watches grab and also the of individuals by way of it has the high-quality plus personal style and design. Right until at this moment, they can be but not only a wrist fake cartier pasha watches and a sign with design flavour. Having said that, fake cartier roadster have access to a prospect for any people who reduced spending plan. You may pay a visit to lots of webpage sellers by using watches providing.
Eat pain zhixia of battle goddess immediately will from virtual shadow in the fell has out, and ground Shang of Mage type goddess didn't has Sisters of tie also active gave up has north face winter coats. though goddess, may she now both with can't vows, and was the north face this melee type character pressure with, wanted to revolt that fundamental is found died. just tie own sisters to so about fortunately said, now even only of hope are was the north face hit has, then revolt that on is found died has."Why sth store sth store?" And fell on the Warrior-goddess of buried his flesh and blood? Mu cylinder fan he north face seems to want to question.